| Popular History of the
1.2 m "Mini" Telescopes
| |
The Beginning of Radio Astronomy
For many centuries, astronomers studied the universe only at optical wavelengths,
enhanced by increasingly more powerful telescopes. Then, in 1929, Bell
Laboratories discovered a strange radio "static" which caused problems for their
new overseas telephone lines. Karl Jansky, an engineer at Bell Labs, was asked
to investigate. By 1933, Jansky had realized that the radio emission came, in fact, from
space, originating somewhere in the direction of the constellation Sagittarius.
By 1944, Grote Reber, the first amateur radio astronomer, had published the
first radio maps of the Milky Way, using a satellite dish he built himself in a
vacant lot next door to his house. In 1951, Edward Purcell and his student
H. I. ("Doc") Ewen detected the first radio signal from atomic
hydrogen (H I) in space. The thought had already entered astronomers' minds
that molecules might also be detected in space using radio waves.
Sure enough, in 1963, radio lines from the hydroxide molecule (OH) was
discovered by Sandy Weinreb and collaborators. About 5 years later, a
team lead by astronomer
Charles H. Townes at Berkeley discovered the first polyatomic molecules, water
(H2O) and ammonia (NH2) in space. As Patrick Thaddeus,
a PhD student of Townes' observed, this "uncorked the bottle" and led the way to many
amazing discoveries in the years ahead.
"Until the war, astronomy was confined
to about an octave, or factor of three, in wavelength, centered on the visual.
And what we've done since then is just explode across the whole
spectrum, so that now astronomy goes from very, very long radio wavelengths,
meters and tens-of-meters long, down to gamma rays. And so to a great degree
what we've been doing is just explode into these empty regions of frequency
space, and in many ways we're still really just doing the survey work. Finding
out what's there, and doing the basic mapping. Every time you go to a new
wavelength band, the general rule is that you find a completely different aspect
of nature in that information." --Pat Thaddeus
|
Molecules in Space--the story continues:
The next major event in our story takes place in 1970, when Arno Penzias, Robert
Wilson, and Keith Jefferts, at Bell Labs, detected carbon monoxide (CO) in space
for the first time. Hydrogen is the simplest and most abundant element in the
universe, and molecular hydrogen (H2) is by far the most abundant
molecule. Unfortunately, under typical interstellar conditions H2
does not emit at radio or millimeter wavelengths. CO, however, the second most
abundant ingredient in molecular clouds, has a rich and strong millimeter-wave
spectrum and it seems to maintain a fairly constant ratio with H2 of
about 1:100,000. For this reason, CO has become the standard tracer or "stain"
for the invisible H2 which constitues most of the molecular mass.
Observations of CO soon reveled that molecular gas in space was much more
extensive than ever suspected.
"You can't see a nucleic acid or protein
within a cell, so you have to use a drop of dye to bring out the structure.
Well, in the densest star-forming regions, we're caught in a similar situation.
We can't see the dominant molecule--molecular hydrogen--either." --Pat
Thaddeus |
Mapping the Giant Molecular Clouds
Initially, Pat Thaddeus and his colleagues, Ken Tucker and Marc Kutner, began
mapping the CO using the sixteen-foot radio telescope at the McDonald
Observatory in western Texas. The plan was to keep mapping outward from the
clouds they were observing (the Orion Nebula and the Horsehead Nebula) until
they found a place where there was no more CO. They soon discovered that there
was so much to be mapped that to do it with that size telescope would take many
years. That large telescope could look at only a very small area of the sky
with each observation. Such high resolution is usually an asset, but when
trying to map large areas of the sky, it becomes a severe liability. Pat
Thaddeus compares it to looking at an elephant with a magnifying glass, or
painting a barn with a quarter-inch brush. Obviously, a larger "brush" was
needed.
"In the early 1970s, an astronomer at
the Goddard Institute of Space Studies in New York named Patrick Thaddeus
shattered centuries of precedent in the field of astronomy and bucked a trend
dating all the way back to Galileo when he decided that, in order to proceed on
a modest project to map the entire Milky Way, he simply did not need and in fact
refused to use a larger telescope made available for his research. He wanted a
small one. In an era made conspicuous by bigger, more sophisticated, and (need
it be added?) more expensive telescopes, Thaddeus insisted on a small and
relatively inexpensive instrument, which he and his colleagues proceeded to
build from scratch." --Stephen S. Hall, Mapping the Next
Millenium |
The "Mini" is born!
Pat Thaddeus and his colleagues designed a radio telescope custom-built for the
task of mapping the entire Galaxy in CO. The "Mini" was designed with a
relatively small dish and consequently a relatively large beamwidth of about 1/8
degree, which can be likened to a wide-angle lens. With this new instrument, it
suddenly became possible to map large stretches of sky in relatively small
amounts of time. The Mini began its life in a rather unlikely spot for a major
research telescope--the 15 story high roof of Pupin Physics Laboratories on
the Columbia campus, just off of upper Broadway in Manhattan. As Sam Palmer,
the electrical engineer who built most of the telescope, says, "It's best to set
up your astronomical operations in the 'center of the universe'." Although
light and human-produced radio interference renders most optical or radio
telescopes useless in a major city like New York, at 2.6 mm, the optimum
wavelength for observing CO, the earth's atmosphere, light, and human noise do
not interfere at all.
"If you live in New York City, if you were to
put on a receiver, you'd discover La Guardia radar and television and radio and
microwave ovens and all these things, a tremendous cacophony. But if you tune
your receiver down--down, down, down, down, down--all of a sudden the cacophony
becomes deathly quiet. We operated this telescope of ours down there, in New
York City, for ten years or so before we came to Harvard, and we during that
whole time did not hear a single peep from the environment. The great
metropolis was as quiet, as I used to say, as the day Henry Hudson sailed up
that river." --Pat Thaddeus |
Using the Superbeam
Over the course of the next several years, a remarkable network of molecular
clouds and filaments was uncovered, extending much further away from the Orion
Nebula than expected. So large was the area covered, in fact, that Pat Thaddeus
and Tom Dame, who had since joined the Columbia group, wished that they had an
even smaller telescope, one which could quickly show them the big
picture. Instead of building a smaller telescope, however, they decided to make
a relatively simple change in the mini's control program. Rather than pointing
at a single spot on the sky, they had the telescope antenna step through a
square array of sixteen points on a 4 x 4 grid (a very cool test of the superbeam
software can be viewed here).
In effect, this allowed the
mini to mimic a smaller antenna with a half-degree beam. Because it is
impossible to view the entire Galaxy from New York, they also built an identical twin of the mini, which was shipped to Cerro Tololo, Chile to observe the southern sky.
"Comparing and combining data from radio
telescopes is generally very difficult because of differences in resolution,
sensitivity, and calibration. But the twin minis provide an unprecedented
opportunity to produce uniform superbeam maps of the entire Milky Way, and,
eventually, of the entire sky. . . .Without the superbeam technique, the twin
minis would have required several decades to map such a large area. Two
telescopes with 1-arc-minute beams (like the antenna at Kitt Peak) could barely
complete the job in two centuries." --Tom Dame (Sky & Telescope, July 1988) |
Molecular Clouds in the Spotlight
Molecular clouds contain about half of the Galaxy's interstellar gas and give birth
to all of its stars. These clouds are typically tens of light-years across and
contain as much gas as a thousand Suns. The largest molecular clouds,
appropriately called Giant Molecular Clouds (GMCs), measure hundreds of
light-years across and weigh as much a million Suns. After a decade of mapping
using the superbeam technique, Tom Dame and Pat Thaddeus had created the first
complete map of the Galaxy in CO, covering more than 7,700 square degrees
(nearly one-fifth of the sky) and representing more than 31,000 individual
observations. The mapping revealed the distribution of molecular gas not only on
the plane of the sky, but also in radial velocity. The large spread of observed
velocities result mainly from the differential rotation of the Galaxy.
"I used to say it was comparable to
the age of Newton, but now I have to say to my students this is by far the best,
most fruitful period of all." --Pat Thaddeus, on the advances being made
today in astronomy |
The Great Move and Beyond
In 1986, the mini was
moved
from New York to the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for
Astrophysics. Since then, it has resided on the roof of the historic "Building
D" here at the Harvard College Observatory. Pat Thaddeus, who occupies a joint
position as a Professor of Astronomy and Applied Physics at Harvard University
and Senior Space Scientist at the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory,
continues to lead the millimeter-wave group. Tom Dame, who also came to Harvard
from Columbia at that time, has coordinated telescope observations over the last
decade, resulting in a second, updated map of the Milky Way, published in 2001.
Sam Palmer continues to maintain the telescope hardware while also
working on equipment at the Spectroscopy Lab. The
telescope observations are finally nearing the conclusion of what was called by
Pat Thaddeus "the zeroth order experiment"--the initial mapping of the Galaxy in
CO--and is searching for ever weaker and more distant signals. It is currently
in operation from October to May each year, working on mapping various sections
of the Milky Way in greater detail and at greater sensitivity, among other
projects.
Quote sources: 1,3,4,6: from the book Mapping the Next Millenium, by Stephen
S. Hall, pages 309, 307, 317, 310 respectively. 2: from the book Thursday's
Universe, by Marcia Bartusiak, page 11. 5: from the July, 1988 issue of Sky and
Telescope magazine, p.24.
Page designed and written by Tamarleigh Lippegrenfell